Separate Universes: The National Book Award/Newbery Overlap

This post over at Tales of an Elementary School Librarian had me thinking about critically acclaimed books that didn’t end up winning awards. I was especially curious about books that were on the National Book Awards shortlist – how many of them have gone on to win a Newbery Honor or Medal? I looked back at the last 10 years. Here are the books that fit this description:

Brown Girl Dreaming

Bomb

Inside Out and Back Again

One Crazy Summer

Claudette Colvin: Twice Toward Justice

This decidedly paltry overlap is maybe best illustrated in this Venn diagram:

I suppose this is the result when two awards use very different methods for highlighting the best books of the year. The National Book Award is a small committee that typically includes a mix of authors, librarians, and booksellers, with relatively few guidelines. Books must be formally submitted for consideration by publishers. The Newbery, on the other hand, is decided by a large group of librarians with a bulkier set of criteria, and books are not formally submitted for consideration. Newbery considers books intended for readers up to age 14, while the NBAs have no such limitation, meaning that they often shortlist more books for older teens.

Maybe you already knew this, but if you’re looking to the National Book Awards to help figure out what’s going to win Newbery, you won’t have much luck.