The 2017 Caldecott Comment Card
Once the winners have been announced, I want to know what you think. Go ahead and share in the comments. Which choice are you happiest with? Which book did the committee miss?
SCROLL TO KEEP READING THIS POST
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Filed under: Articles
About Travis Jonker
Travis Jonker is an elementary school librarian in Michigan. He writes reviews (and the occasional article or two) for School Library Journal and is a member of the 2014 Caldecott committee. You can email Travis at scopenotes@gmail.com, or follow him on Twitter: @100scopenotes.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
100 Scope Notes
A Random Student Sticky Note: The Only Book Review You Need
A Fuse #8 Production
Review of the Day: Pina by Elif Yemenici, translated by Sydney Wade
Good Comics for Kids
Recent Graphic Novel Deals, Early Sep 2022 | News
Teen Librarian Toolbox
Music, Mythology, and Misanthropy: The inspiration behind My Name is Magic, a guest post by Xan van Rooyen
The Classroom Bookshelf
The Classroom Bookshelf is Moving
ADVERTISEMENT
Happiest about Radiant Child & Freedom in Congo Square
Book they missed: The Night Gardener
Happiest about: all the love for MARCH
Book they missed: Some Writer!
Happiest about Radiant Child! (And that somehow we called every book in our Mock list).
Book they missed: The Princess and the Warrior
Happiest About: They All Saw A Cat and Freedom in Congo Square
Book They Missed: Some Writer!
Happiest About: They All Saw a Cat
Book(s) They Missed: Some Writer!, Before Morning and The Night Gardener
Happiest About: March and John Lewis
Book They Missed: Some Writer!
Oops, I realize March wasn’t a Caldecott…. but I was very excited about all the love it got this morning!
Yes – that was great to see!
Caldecott:
Happiest About: Congrats to all – a fantastic mix, and such a delight to see Leave Me Alone included.
Book They Missed: Thunder Boy Jr. and This is Not a Picture Book.
Everything else:
Thrilled about: March Book 3, of course. The Girl Who Drank the Moon. When the Moon Was Ours. Nimona! Goodnight Owl. Go, Otto, Go! Jason Reynolds. Ashley Bryan.
Book they Missed: When the Sea Turned to Silver. The Princess in Black and the Hungry Bunny Horde. Up!
Happiest about: Du Iz Tak. A book that will be enjoyed all over the world for decades to come.
Books They Missed: Some Writer!; The Tree in the Courtyard; School’s First Day of School.
Everything else: Judging awards season as a whole, including Zolotow et cetera., diversity interests continue to be a massive influence on selection and types of awards made.
Happiest About: Freedom in Congo Square and They All Saw a Cat
Book They Missed: The Storyteller
But honestly, I think this year’s committees did a marvelous job on all fronts. The more words MARCH one, the happier and more excited I became. What a resounding success! Newbery committee also nailed it this year. Four extraordinary selections.
Happiest about They All Saw a Cat; missed The Night Gardener
Happiest About: Du Iz Tak? – Even with the buzz it has received, I still feel like this is an underrated gem.
Book They Missed: School’s First Day of School 🙁
My students would say Are We There Yet?
I can only comment on Caldecotts as we held a Mock at my school. Wonderful choices, all.
Books they missed: Maybe Something Beautiful, The Airport Book, Before Morning.
Happiest about: THEY ALL SAW A CAT & DU IZ TAK?
Book Missed: BE A FRIEND
Happiest about: The Girl Who Drank the Moon and They All Saw a Cat
Book they missed: Real Cowboys
Happiest About: They All Saw a Cat
Book They Missed: Shy
Happiest about: RADIANT CHILD and FREEDOM IN CONGO SQUARE! Two that I was pulling for. And LEAVE ME ALONE was an unexpected surprise!
Book they missed: REAL COWBOYS is a hidden gem. Shared it with my mother-in-law, a retired librarian, and she couldn’t stop gushing about the artwork. I love the harmony between the text and the illustrations! So I’ll keep loving it and sharing it on my own 🙂
But overall, just want to echo so many others in saying it’s a wonderful slate of selections, and particularly pleased to see so many relatively up-and-coming illustrators recognized!
Happiest About: They All Saw a Cat
Book They Missed: Night Gardener
Happiest about: THE GIRL WHO DRANK THE MOON.
Book they missed: SOME WRITER!
Happiest About: They All Saw a Cat & The Girl Who Drank the Moon
Books They Missed: Shy & Some Kind of Courage
Happiest about They All Saw A Cat. Books missed: School’s First Day of School, Be A Friend.
Happiest about: They All Saw a Cat
Books They Missed: The Night Gardener, Are We There Yet?
Happiest about LEAVE ME ALONE.
Missed: SNOW WHITE.
Happiest about: Du Iz Tak
Book they missed: The Night Gardener
Happiest about:They All Saw A Cat
Book They Missed: Ghost, Some Writer
Happiest about: They All Saw a Cat
Book They Missed: Some Writer!, The Night Gardener