1992: Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
Original Cover:
My Redo:
Side by Side:
Verdict: I went photo, which I like to try to avoid, but this is one time where I think the kid interest would be high. As the old book cover adage goes – “when in doubt, put a dog on the cover”.
Up next week: Missing May by Cynthia Rylant
(Source Image: “Good Boy” http://flic.kr/p/d3WxrW)
About Travis Jonker
I would love to have the name of the fonts you use in your post. Just in case one catches my eye.
About the cover – I’m not fond of the original art, but it does capture the relationship.
Hi David – I use the website PicMonkey for all the covers: http://www.picmonkey.com/
The fonts this time out were Pencil Pete and Chelsea Market.
My kids all love the Shiloh series! They read it in 4th grade as part of a class assignment.
I remember loving that cover when I was a kid! I felt like it beautifully captured the moral dilemma he was going through… the doubt and uncertainty and love for the dog and desire to do the right thing…
I agree – my re-do doesn’t have that, to be sure.
I prefer your cover!
Your re-design is awesome. It would’ve pulled me in as a kid–and I’m not even a dog person…