SUBSCRIBE
SUBSCRIBE
SLJ Blog Network +
  • 100 Scope Notes
  • A Fuse #8 Production
  • Good Comics for Kids
  • Heavy Medal: A Mock Newbery Blog
  • Teen Librarian Toolbox
  • The Classroom Bookshelf
  • The Yarn
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About/Contact
  • *Best New Books*
    • Annual Best Lists
  • Reviews
    • One Star Review
    • Nonfiction
    • Toon Reviews
  • Articles
    • Authors
    • Link Du Jour
  • Covers
    • Covering the Newbery
    • Cover Curiosity
    • Unfortunate Covers
  • News
    • Books on Film
    • Morning Notes
  • Newsletter

September 15, 2015 by Travis Jonker

I Am Not An Artist: The Biggest (And Oldest) Knock on the Caldecott

September 15, 2015 by Travis Jonker   11 comments

Why Cats Paint

Calling Caldecott, the Horn Book-housed blog all about the most prestigious award in picture books, is back up and running (click here to visit).

SCROLL TO KEEP READING THIS POST

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Over the coming months they’ll examine a bunch of books that are knocking collective socks off.

It reminded me of a conversation I had with an illustrator at the most recent ALA Annual. We were talking about Caldecott, and specifically the idea of non-artists critiquing art. This illustrator thought there should be more guidance for those on the committee. Maybe adding a member who was an expert or some other way for the committee to have more facility when it comes to discussing art.

It’s a debate that’s been going on for a long time, probably since the award was created. It’s interesting to think how it would change the Caldecott. *Update* And it’s a conversation, Julie Danielson reminds us in her comment below, that’s taken place at Calling Caldecott.

To the illustrator’s point, I think there is a varying degree of art-specific expertise among the Caldecott committee – some folks come with a lot of previous experience, others less so.

In defense, I would say the committee members do work hard to educate (or refresh) themselves on all things illustration before and during their service. Members are provided with a reading list (see page 24 of the Caldecott manual) of excellent resources to help expand their knowledge.

What do you think? Should the Caldecott committee have more artistic guidance?

Filed under: Articles

SHARE:

Read or Leave Comments

About Travis Jonker

Travis Jonker is an elementary school librarian in Michigan. He writes reviews (and the occasional article or two) for School Library Journal and is a member of the 2014 Caldecott committee. You can email Travis at scopenotes@gmail.com, or follow him on Twitter: @100scopenotes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

January 2023

Your 2023 Caldecott Comment Card

by Travis Jonker

January 2023

Who's Published the Most Newbery Winners in the Last 25 Years?

by Travis Jonker

January 2023

2023 Caldecott Medal Predictions

by Travis Jonker

January 2023

The Ten Most Eye-Opening Caldecott Books of All Time

by Travis Jonker

January 2023

Enter the World of Incredibly Specific Children's Literature Instagram Accounts

by Travis Jonker

ADVERTISEMENT

SLJ Blog Network

100 Scope Notes

Your 2023 Caldecott Comment Card

by Travis Jonker

A Fuse #8 Production

Fuse 8 n’ Kate: Will Spring Be Early? Or Will Spring Be Late? by Crockett Johnson

by Betsy Bird

Good Comics for Kids

Monkey Prince Vol. 1: Enter the Monkey | Review

by J. Caleb Mozzocco

Heavy Medal

Heavy Medal Mock Newbery Readers’ Poll Results

by Steven Engelfried

Teen Librarian Toolbox

Philosophy and/as/of Literature, a guest post by Amy Zhang

by Amanda MacGregor

The Classroom Bookshelf

The Classroom Bookshelf is Moving

by Erika Thulin Dawes

The Yarn

A Book 25 Years in the Making: Marla Frazee Visits The Yarn

by Travis Jonker

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Articles on SLJ

6 Chapter Books Series Updates for Transitioning Readers

6 Middle Grade & YA Novels on Repeat for Groundhog Day

The Roads Taken: Kids’ love of things that go puts transportation books front and center | Great Books

Remember: 10 Titles to Read for Holocaust Remembrance Day

ChatGPT Does Readers’ Advisory | Top Stories on SLJ

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. jules says

    September 15, 2015 at 10:06 am

    You may already know this, but this was also discussed at Calling Caldecott two years ago. I still remember that conversation, and here’s the link for those who want even more food-for-thought: http://www.hbook.com/2013/10/featured/whos-committee-barry-moser-question/#_

    • Travis Jonker says

      September 15, 2015 at 10:10 am

      Thanks for linking this, Jules – definitely a discussion that’s been kicking around for a long time

  2. Carter Higgins says

    September 15, 2015 at 11:42 am

    Whether or not this should be a thing, it makes me itchy when we don’t honor the process. I can’t imagine that committee members are all WHATEVS about it. Because the committee members are all experts in story, and I’d argue that you don’t need an art degree to have a feeling from it, to read its story. (Though I do love the conversation, and pipe up about it from time to time and read all of the chatter about it with eager eyes!)

    • Travis Jonker says

      September 16, 2015 at 8:27 am

      I’m with you here, Carter

  3. Carter Higgins says

    September 15, 2015 at 11:43 am

    (Also remember when I told you I wasn’t ready for all the hubbub? I think I changed my mind. I realized this is the last year I can go librarian-gangbusters over it all, because once I have books out I’m sure my POV will change dramatically!)

  4. Jonathan Hunt says

    September 15, 2015 at 4:21 pm

    I must disagree with your illustrator friend there, Travis. I think people need to read the criteria a little bit more closely. I often hear people say something along these lines: Newbery is for text and Caldecott is for art. And that’s really not true at all. The Caldecott is given to the most distinguished American picture book for children–not the best art–and further the criteria call for . . .

    Excellence of execution in the artistic technique employed;
    Excellence of pictorial interpretation of story, theme, or concept;
    Appropriateness of style of illustration to the story, theme or concept;
    Delineation of plot, theme, characters, setting, mood or information through the pictures;
    Excellence of presentation in recognition of a child audience.

    You really only need an artistic background for the first one; the remaining four criteria have as much to do with the narrative as they do the art. Right?

    When people recommend that the committee needs somebody with an art background, they don’t realize that out of fifteen people on the committee there are probably several of them who do indeed have that formal background in art. The rest of them work very hard throughout the year to get there.

    The implication is that if only somebody did have that background that the committee would have better Taste. Sadly, that’s not the case. We’ve seen awards that have been doled out with the benefit of illustrators or exclusively by illustrators and those books are not any more inspiring, more or less, than the Caldecott choices.

    • Travis Jonker says

      September 16, 2015 at 8:26 am

      Well put, Jonathan – thanks for add your thoughts here

  5. marjorie says

    September 15, 2015 at 5:36 pm

    I just want to say I LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE Why Cats Paint. 🙂

    • Travis Jonker says

      September 16, 2015 at 8:26 am

      Ha! Yeah, I’ve only seen the cover – I need to see more

  6. Starr LaTronica says

    September 22, 2015 at 11:23 am

    For those who would like delve deeper into the artists’ process of illustration, The Society of Illustrators offers an informative and inspiring annual event geared specifically for librarians:

    READING PICTURES: The Artist’s Voice and Vocabulary in Picture Books
    Monday, November 16th, 1 pm – 8pm. The Society of Illustrators, 128 East 63rd Street NYC

    Illustrators Diane Dillon, Floyd Cooper and Carin Berger will share their behind-the-scenes decisions and discuss and/or demonstrate their creative process in the intimate gallery setting of the annual Original Art Exhibit. Art Directors from major children’s publishers will lead a gallery talk of this spectacular show for a close-up examination of the works on view.

    $30 registration fee includes program and tour, gallery admission (value $10), catalog (value $10) and small plates buffet supper.

    For details and registration please visit http://www.societyillustrators.org/Product.aspx?id=13430

    • Travis Jonker says

      September 22, 2015 at 8:14 pm

      Thanks for mentioning this, Starr!

ADVERTISEMENT

Archives

  • Author/Illustrator Blogs

    • Erin Stead Illustration
    • Hey, Rabbit!
    • James Preller's Blog
    • MATTHEWCORDELLBLOGS
    • Mo Willems Doodles
    • The Scop
  • Book Blogs I Like

    • A Book and a Hug
    • A Fuse #8 Production
    • A Kids Book a Day
    • A Year of Reading
    • Abby (the) Librarian
    • Awful Library Books
    • Becky’s Book Reviews
    • Better Book Titles
    • Book-A-Day Almanac
    • Bookends
    • books4yourkids.com
    • bookshelves of doom
    • Bottom Shelf Books
    • Calling Caldecott
    • Caustic Cover Critic
    • Chad C. Beckerman
    • Charlotte’s Library
    • Cheryl Rainfield
    • Chicken Spaghetti
    • CHILDREN’S ILLUSTRATION
    • Collecting Children’s Books
    • Cybils
    • EarlyWord
    • educating alice
    • Finding Wonderland
    • For Those About to Mock
    • Good Comics for Kids
    • Good Show Sir
    • GottaBook
    • Great Kid Books
    • Heavy Medal: A Mock Newbery Blog
    • Hi Miss Julie!
    • Jen Robinson’s Book Page
    • Kidsmomo
    • Maria T. Middleton Design
    • Nerdy Book Club
    • Neverending Search
    • Nine Kinds of Pie
    • One Book, Two Books, Old Books, New Books
    • Out of the Box
    • Oz and Ends
    • PlanetEsme
    • Read Roger
    • Reading Rants!
    • Seven Impossible Things Before Breakfast
    • sharpread
    • ShelfTalker
    • so tomorrow
    • The Children's Book Review
    • The Miss Rumphius Effect
    • Uncovered Cover Art
    • Waking Brain Cells
    • Watch. Connect. Read.
  • Library Blogs

    • ALSC Blog
    • Blue Skunk Blog
    • librarian.net
    • LISNews
    • Stephen's Lighthouse
    • Tame The Web: Libraries and Technology
    • Tame The Web: Libraries and Technology
    • Unshelved
  • Follow This Blog

    Enter your email address below to receive notifications of new blog posts by email.

    This coverage is free for all visitors. Your support makes this possible.

    This coverage is free for all visitors. Your support makes this possible.

    Primary Sidebar

    • News & Features
    • Reviews+
    • Technology
    • School Libraries
    • Public Libraries
    • Age Level
    • Ideas
    • Blogs
    • Classroom
    • Diversity
    • People
    • Job Zone

    Reviews+

    • Book Lists
    • Best Books
    • Media
    • Reference
    • Series Made Simple
    • Tech
    • Review for SLJ
    • Review Submissions

    SLJ Blog Network

    • 100 Scope Notes
    • A Fuse #8 Production
    • Good Comics for Kids
    • Heavy Medal
    • Neverending Search
    • Teen Librarian Toolbox
    • The Classroom Bookshelf
    • The Yarn

    Resources

    • 2022 Youth Media Awards
    • The Newbery at 100: SLJ Celebrates the 100th Anniversary of the Award
    • Special Report | School Libraries 2021
    • Summer Reading 2021
    • Series Made Simple Spring 2021
    • SLJ Diverse Books Survey
    • Summer Programming Survey
    • Research
    • White Papers / Case Studies
    • School Librarian of the Year
    • Mathical Book Prize Collection Development Awards
    • Librarian/Teacher Collaboration Award

    Events & PD

    • In-Person Events
    • Online Courses
    • Virtual Events
    • Webcasts
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Subscribe
    • Media Inquiries
    • Newsletter Sign Up
    • Content Submissions
    • Data Privacy
    • Terms of Use
    • Terms of Sale
    • FAQs
    • Diversity Policy
    • Careers at MSI


    COPYRIGHT © 2023


    COPYRIGHT © 2023