Nontraditional Nonfiction Monday: What Do I Do?
On May 24th I’ll be hosting Nonfiction Monday (click here for a description). I thought it would be fun to call it Nontraditional Nonfiction Monday and challenge bloggers to review a book in a different way. In case you missed it, here’s the video announcement:
So, the question arises – how to go about this nontraditional review? Here are some ideas:
- Create a cartoon review. I’m partial to the comic-creating website Bitstrips, but you can also try the very nice looking Make Beliefs Comix. Click here to check out my Toon Review of One Crazy Summer for ideas.
- Get in character and write a review from a different perspective. Reviewing a book about trees? Write it from the perspective of a tree. I did something along these lines when I reviewed The Curious Garden from the perspective of the book’s message (yeah, not making much sense – click here to see what I mean).
- Write a flow chart review. The excellent Art of Irreverence blog created one of these a while back, and the results were nothing short of winning. Click here to read it.
- Two words: animated review. I’ve been wanting to try this out, but haven’t worked up the vim. Go! Animate is the site to create your masterpiece.
- Have your review mirror the style of the book. It is a poetry book? Write a poem review. Is it a how-to guide? Write a how-to review. I tried something like this with my review of Show Off.
- Try your hand at a video review. You can get fancy and make it all movie-like, of you can just turn on your camera and let us know what you think.
- For aspiring children’s lit Willie Nelsons, write a song review. I’m teaming up with the blog Hi Miss Julie! to do exactly this. Grab your guitar, piano, or Garageband and give it a try.
- Here’s a challenge. Write a Twitter review. Trying to describe a book in 140 characters will have you driving yourself crazy in no time.
- Recruit a friend/colleague and try a tag-team review. One book – two perspectives. The Booklist blog Bookends is a great example of this.
“Hold your horses”, you say? Too crazy? No problem – anything out of your reviewing norm will work. And of course, standard reviews are also welcome.
Do you have other nontraditional review ideas? Share them in the comments.
6 Responses to Nontraditional Nonfiction Monday: What Do I Do?
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
Scope Notes to Your Inbox
ALA Annual

About
Travis Jonker is an elementary school librarian in Michigan. He reviews children's books for School Library Journal and is a member of the American Library Association. You can email Travis at scopenotes@gmail.com. He's also on...
Archives
Author/Illustrator Blogs
Children's Lit Blogs
- *Chasing Ray*
- 2¢ Worth
- 36 Pages
- A Chair, A Fireplace & A Tea Cozy
- A Curious Thing
- A Fuse #8 Production
- A Year of Reading
- AASL Personal Members Archive Feed
- ABA Blogs
- Abby (the) Librarian
- ACPL Mock Caldecott
- ACPL Mock Newbery
- AL Censorship Watch
- ALA TechSource Blog
- Becky’s Book Reviews
- Better Book Titles
- book scout
- Book Talk
- Book-A-Day Almanac
- Bookends
- BookMoot
- books4yourkids.com
- bookshelves of doom
- Booktalking
- Bottom Shelf Books
- Calling Caldecott
- Caustic Cover Critic
- Charlotte’s Library
- Cheryl Rainfield:
- Chicken Spaghetti
- Children’s Books and Reviews
- CHILDREN’S ILLUSTRATION
- Collecting Children’s Books
- Cybils
- CYNSATIONS
- e is for book
- EarlyWord
- educating alice
- Finding Wonderland
- For Those About to Mock
- Good Comics for Kids
- Good Show Sir
- GottaBook
- Great Kid Books
- Heavy Medal: A Mock Newbery Blog
- Hi Miss Julie!
- In the Pages….
- INK
- JACKET KNACK
- Jacket Whys
- Jen Robinson’s Book Page
- Just One More Book!!
- Kidlitosphere Central
- Kids Lit
- Kids’ Comics
- Kidsmomo
- Klickitat
- librarian.net
- Library Voice
- Life in Jersey
- LISNews:
- Litandmore
- Literary Asylum
- Literate Lives
- MacKids Home
- Maria T. Middleton Design
- mental_floss Blog » At the Libraries
- Mishaps and Adventures
- MotherReader
- NeverEndingSearch
- Nine Kinds of Pie
- Nonfiction Monday
- Omnivoracious
- One Book, Two Books, Old Books, New Books
- Out of the Box
- Oz and Ends
- Picture Book of the Day
- Picture Books Review
- Pink Me
- PlanetEsme
- Playing by the book
- Pop Culture Junkie
- Read Roger
- Read, Read, Read
- Reading Rants!
- Reads for Keeps
- ROGUE LIBRARIAN
- Seven Impossible Things Before Breakfast
- sharpread
- ShelfTalker
- Six Boxes of Books
- so tomorrow:
- TEACHERNINJA
- The Chained Library
- The Children’s Book Review
- The Digital Shift
- The Miss Rumphius Effect
- the pageturn
- Three Silly Chicks
- Touch and Go
- Uncovered Cover Art
- Under the Covers
- Underage Reading
- Waking Brain Cells
- Watch. Connect. Read.
- Welcome to my Tweendom
- What Adrienne Thinks About That
- What We Read and What We Think
- Young Readers




Here’s a challenge. Write a Twitter review. Trying to describe a book in 140 characters will have you driving yourself crazy in no time.
Oh yeah, you could also recruit a friend/colleague and try a tag-team review. One book – two perspectives. The Booklist blog Bookends is a great example of this. Here’s an example http://bookends.booklistonline.com/2010/04/21/lmno-peas-by-keith-baker/
Travis, your blog is constantly filled with great stuff. Your library must be buzzing with creativity and enthusiasm. Thanks for taking the time to share your passion with the world. It’s catchy – and inspiring!
I love this idea. Now to get busy coming up with a Nontraditional review worthy of your idea…
Alright! Bookends is in! I look forward to what you come up with.
This is such a great idea, and I love these suggestions! How about a fiction one sometime? My two extras are Xtranormal for a little movie animation, and ToonDoo for a cartoon.